Wikipedia:Featured topic criteria
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Good content: Good and featured topic tools:
|
A good topic or a featured topic is a collection of articles that represents Wikipedia's best work in covering a subject comprehensively and with items of consistently good quality. In addition to meeting the requirements for all Wikipedia articles by all of its constituents, a good or featured topic has the following attributes.
- It is a set of similar, interrelated articles that cover a specific topic.
- (a) There are at least three distinct articles.
- (b) The articles have a clear similarity with each other under a well-defined topical scope.
- (c) All articles in the topic are linked together, preferably using a template, and share a common category or super-category.
- (d) There is no obvious gap (missing or stub article) in the topic. A topic must not cherry pick only the best articles to become featured together.
- (e) For overview topics, every article within the scope of the topic that is not included in the topic should also be within the scope of a non-lead article that is included in the topic.
- The topic has an introductory and summary lead article or list.
- Each article is of high quality, including the referencing.
- (a) With featured topics only:
- (i) At least one third of the articles are featured class (featured articles or featured lists), with a minimum of two featured items.
- (ii) All other articles are good articles.
- (b) With good topics only:
- (i) All articles are at least featured lists or good articles.
- (c) Items that are ineligible for featured article, featured list or good article status, either due to their limited subject matter (in the case of lists only) or due to inherent instability (in the case of either articles or lists), must have passed an individual quality audit that included a completed peer review, with all important problems fixed. Such items do not count towards criteria 1.a., 3.a.ii., or 3.b.i.
- (a) With featured topics only:
[edit] Recommendations
In addition to the mandatory criteria above, it is recommended that all topics meet the following optional criteria:
- The structure of the articles is similar, with the same section titles and order where possible.
- The articles use a common infobox where appropriate.
- The topic has a free use image to accompany and represent the topic if at all possible.
- The topic is not overly large nor needlessly small. There is no maximum number of articles, but if something is far larger than existing topics, it might be wise to split it into subtopics. For example, science fiction films would be too large a topic, but Star Trek films would be of appropriate scope. Conversely, a topic should not be excessively sub-divided; an all-encompassing topic of five articles is better than two topics of three each. These guidelines do not apply to items in a clear series (every article from 1st Canadian Parliament to 40th Canadian Parliament could be included in one topic), or those dictated by geography (for example, states of the USA).
- The topic does not overly overlap with a current good or featured topic.
- Before nominating a topic, nominators may wish to receive feedback by listing it at Featured topic questions. Nominators must be sufficiently familiar with the subject matter and sources to deal with objections during the FTC process. If you nominate something you have worked on, note it as a self-nomination. Nominators who are not significant contributors to the articles of the topic should consult regular editors of the articles prior to nomination. Nominators are expected to respond positively to constructive criticism and to make an effort to address objections promptly.
- To avoid wasting time, the topic should not have any active Good article nominations, Good article reassessments, Featured article reviews, Featured article removal candidates, Featured list candidates, or Featured list removal candidates when nominated for good or featured topic, and should only have Peer reviews or Featured article candidates if the result does not affect whether the topic meets the good/featured topic criteria. Please have all required processes done before nominating. Nominations with one or more articles involved in a process mentioned above may result in a quick fail.
[edit] Retention
- Good and featured topic status is dependent on the continued adherence to all criteria, including retention of high quality status by all of the constituents. If any of the criteria are no longer met, or any constituents lose quality status, such topics will be eligible for a topic removal nomination after a grace period. The grace period will be three months for a demotion of an article or if the topic expands and is therefore incomplete and six months following a change to the Good or Featured Topic criteria.
[edit] Current Retention Periods
- Guitar Hero series has
- until 2009-06-04 to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.c. with article Guitar Hero: Smash Hits.
- until 2009-06-16 to meet criterion 3.a with article Guitar Hero: Smash Hits.
- until 2009-07-19 to meet criterion 1.d. and 3.c. with articles Guitar Hero: On Tour series and List of songs in the Guitar Hero On Tour series.
- Atlantic Coast Conference football championship games has until 2009-05-22 to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.c. with article 2009 ACC Championship Game.
- The Legend of Zelda titles has
- until 2009-06-25 to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.c. with article The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks.
- until 2009-08-31 to meet criteria 3.b. with article The Legend of Zelda (series).
- Seasons of Bleach has
- until 2009-07-07 to meet criteria 3.a. with article List of Bleach episodes (season 10).
- until 2009-07-14 to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.c. with article List of Bleach episodes (season 11).
- X-Men films has until 2009-07-30 to meet criteria 3.b. with article X-Men Origins: Wolverine.
- Seasons of Lost has until 2009-08-13 to meet criterion 3.a. with article Lost (season 5).
- Seasons of The Office (US TV series) has until 2009-08-14 to meet criterion 3.a. with article The Office (US TV series) season 5.
- Seasons of 30 Rock has until 2009-08-14 to meet criterion 3.a with article 30 Rock (season 3).
- National Basketball Association awards has until 2009-08-30 to meet criteria 3.a. with article Walter A. Brown Trophy.
- Halo media has until 2009-09-03 to meet criterion 3.a with article Halo: Uprising.
- Final Fantasy XII has until 2009-09-17 to meet criteria 3.a. with article Characters of Final Fantasy XII.
- Jesus College, Oxford has until 2009-09-23 to met criteria 3.1 with article Buildings of Jesus College, Oxford
[edit] Future Retention Periods
- From 2009-08-14, Seasons of Bleach will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a with article Bleach (season 11).
- From 2009-09-22, Halo media will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a. with article Halo 3: ODST.
- From 2009-09-30, Kingdom Hearts will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a. with article Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days.
- From 2009-12-05, Atlantic Coast Conference football championship games will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a. with article 2009 ACC Championship Game.
- From the airing of the finale of Degrassi: The Next Generation (season 8), Seasons of Degrassi: The Next Generation will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a.
- From the creation of articles Guitar Hero 5, Guitar Hero: Van Halen, Band Hero, and Guitar Hero: Hendrix, Guitar Hero series will have 3 months to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.a.
- From the release date of Guitar Hero On Tour: Modern Hits, Guitar Hero series will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a. with articles Guitar Hero: On Tour series and List of songs in the Guitar Hero On Tour series.
- From the creation of article Half-Life 2: Episode Three, Half-Life 2 titles will have 3 months to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.a.
- From the release date of Halo: Reach, Halo media will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a.
- From the release date of Rewrite (visual novel), Video games developed by Key will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.b.
- From the release dates of Kingdom Hearts coded and Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep, Kingdom Hearts will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a.
- From the release date of The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks, The Legend of Zelda titles will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a.
- From the creation of article Pirates of the Caribbean 4, Pirates of the Caribbean films will have 3 months to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.b.
- From the creation of articles Spider-Man 4, Spider-Man 5 and Venom (film), Spider-Man films will have 3 months to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.b.
- From the release date of StarCraft II, StarCraft titles will have 3 months to meet criterion 3.a.
- From the creation of article 2009 World Series of Poker Europe, World Series of Poker Europe will have 3 months to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.b.
- From the creation of articles Deadpool (film), X-Men: First Class (film), X-Men Origins: Magneto and X-Men Origins: Wolverine 2, X-Men films will have 3 months to meet criteria 1.d. and 3.b.

